Before crashing, recompute the path lengths and identify the controlling path.
Path A-B-D
Path A-B-D has baseline length 8.
Path A-C-D
Path A-C-D has baseline length 7.
Baseline critical path
The longer baseline path is A-B-D, so it controls the project finish.
baseline critical path=A−B−D
Deadline gap
The deadline is shorter than the baseline duration, so the displayed plan needs a reduction.
baseline exceeds deadline