When rho is less than one, the cross term is smaller than in the same-move case. For the same fifty-fifty portfolio, variance falls from 9/400 to 1/80 at zero rho, and to 1/400 at rho -1.
ρ<1⇒σp2 can fall
Exact comparison
The exact comparison is variance, not rounded sigma. The rounded sigma values are 15.00%, 11.18%, and 5.00% for the three rho cases.
σp=σp2
Diversification input
Diversification depends on the stated sigma and rho inputs. In the real world those inputs are estimated from data with uncertainty. This is descriptive, not investment advice.